Site icon Shroud of Turin Blog

Is my mind closed? Or is it the other guy?

imageThis morning, I received an email from a “committed skeptic” who told me it is only a matter of time until someone “really figures out” how the shroud’s image was formed. “When that happens,” he wrote, “you will have absolute proof that [the shroud] is a forgery. That is the only assertion acceptable to science.”

The only assertion acceptable to science? Really?

I was reminded of an exchange of emails I had with Ray Rogers in  December of 2004. I mentioned to him that I get significant numbers of emails from the “lunatic fringe.”

I WROTE:  Ray, you wrote [in a previous email]: "Apparently no amount of physical law or illustration can successfully argue against a strong desire to prove the resurrection facts or not."

Sadly, it cuts both ways. . .

His reply was classic, Rogers. Two paragraphs, in particular, were priceless. In the first he  responded to me about a similar email he received with a new explanation for the images:

ROGERS WROTE:  Yes. I get lots of lunatic-fringe mail too – – – and telephone calls. Some of the calls come in the middle of the night…perhaps catalyzed by too much Pinot Noir. My favorite was a guy who pointed out that when you cover a "daid boddie" with a cloth, the flies come to the smell. "They poke their little noses through the cloth. And you know what flies leave – – – little black specks. "Jest look at that image real close, and you will see that it is made up of a whole bunch of fly specks." By that time I was rolling on the floor, and I couldn’t answer him.

The next paragraph below was in response to the fact that

I WROTE:  . . . a distinguished Yale research biologist, told me recently, ‘It’s art. I can see that it’s art. There is no amount of scientific fact that could convince me otherwise.’

Ray’s response:

ROGERS WROTE:  Like you, I had one of the top (Manhattan Project) scientists (and a staunch Episcopalian) at the Laboratory tell me, "Ray, even if you prove that thing is real, I won’t believe it." Many people do not stop to wonder what "real" means in the context of the Shroud.

Is my mind closed? Or is it the other guy?

Exit mobile version